FOLLOW me on my popular Twitter feed. Just click this photo! @hbbtruth - David - Common sense on #Politics #PublicPolicy #Sports #PopCulture in USA, Great Britain, Sweden and France, via my life in #Texas #Memphis #Miami #IU #Chicago #DC #FL ๐ซ๐๐บ๐ฝ️๐. This photo of Cary Grant and Grace Kelly in Alfred Hitchcock's 1955 classic "To Catch a Thief" is the large Twitter photo on my @hbbtruth account
Beautiful Strandvรคgen, the grand boulevard in รstermalm, in central Stockholm, Sweden, along Nybroviken. In my previous life, I was DEFINITELY born and raised there!
Memorial Stadium, Bloomington, home of the Hoosiers; Fernando Mendoza TD dive on 4th Down leads to IU's first nat'l football title; The Team; The Head Coach, Curt Cignetti and the Hoosiers 2026 football schedule
South Florida Sun-Sentinel's Broward Politics blog video: Broward County Clerk Howard C. Forman says mushrooming red-light cameras -and tickets- will create new pressures on resources/finances of Broward Courts http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=B-n3bKZnZs4
The South Florida Sun-Sentinel's Broward Politics blog is at:http://weblogs.sun-sentinel.com/news/politics/broward/blog/ ----- Tuesday morning's Broward County Commission agenda includes the red-light camera issue, which is why I will likely be there on TuesdayIFI can switch some things around in my schedule.
Regardless of whether I can attend Ruesday morning in person or not, I will post the information and photographs I want to make them aware of here on the blog by 9 a.m. and email it to them. Please come back here Tuesday morning so you can see for yourself what this program looks like in Hallandale Beach, and judge whether or not it seems reasonable or well-executed.
Honorable Mayor Gunzburger, Vice Mayor Rodstrom and County Commissioners,
I am not a supporter of "redlight" cameras not because I want people to break the law and get away with it. I am against it because my city, Hallandale Beach has done such a poor job installing a redlight camera about a year before the State actually allowed them. The City made it a "code violation" and collected about 2 million dollars for not stopping twice or three times prior to turning right on red. That is not the issue I am writing about now. We will fight that battle with our City Commission.
I understand you will vote on allowing the cities to tie into the County's traffic control system. I am not in favor of it but if you do I urge you to make a small amendment to the ordinance.
If they want to tie into the system, any intersection with traffic cameras should have a "count down" device next to it, similar to the one you see at cross walks. That would warn law abiding citizens to get ready to stop and avoid rear end collisions. Cities collect plenty of money from fines to absorb the additional expense.
I hope you decide to consider my suggestion, it would make redlight cameras safer and more palatable to the residents of Broward County.
Sincerely,
Csaba Kulin
Vice President
United Condominium Associations of Hallandale Beach
Late this afternoon, a post by Brittany Wallman bout the red-light camera issue was posted at Broward Politics blog.
Broward's Rodstrom offers counterproposal to red light cameras By Brittany Wallman February 28, 2011 06:11 PM
Drivers already hate sitting at red lights. Maybe they’ll get to hate it for two seconds longer.One Broward County commissioner suggests that would be a better way to keep motorists safe from red-light runners than watching them with enforcement cameras.
Read the rest of the post at: http://weblogs.sun-sentinel.com/news/politics/broward/blog/2011/02/browards_rodstrom_offers_count.html
-----
The bill in the Florida State House to repeal red-light cameras is Bill 4087, which was filed by State Rep. Richard Corcoran, R-New Port Richey, and the companion in the State Senate is Senate Bill 672, filed by Sen. Garcia, whose district is based out of Hialeah. Broward PoliticsYouTube Channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/BrowardPolitics
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/videobeta/5bd7737d-1fb4-4da7-bb7d-13007f44c83b/News/Broward-Schools-Superintendent-James-Notter-takes-responsibility-for-a-failing-report-but-won-t-retire This video goes with O'Matz and Fitzpatrick article of February 23, 2011 below The embed code causes the video to appear here twice.
BrowardPalmBeach New Times Daily Pulp Grand Jury Report: School Board Blew Hundreds of Millions of Taxpayers Dollars While In Lobbyists' PocketBy Bob Norman, Sat., Feb. 19 2011 @ 6:36AM
Well, it's finally official.
The Broward County School Board wasted hundreds of millions of your dollars while doing the bidding of a select group of contractors and lobbyists. You've been reading about that here for the past five years. Now the statewide grand jury has found the same thing.
The final grand jury report was released last night (yes, that means they aren't going to issue indictments). To get an idea of its tone, understand that it stated flatly that were it not for a constitutional mandate to have a school board "our first and foremost recommendation would have been to abolish the Broward County School Board altogether."
Read the rest of the post at: http://blogs.browardpalmbeach.com/pulp/2011/02/broward_schools_grand_jury_report.php ----- BrowardPalmBeach New Times Daily Pulp Grand Jury Slams Jennifer Gottlieb's "Beachside Boondoggle" By Bob Norman, Sun., Feb. 20 2011 @ 8:38AM
The Sun-Sentinel obtained some comments from school boarder defending themselves from the findings of the statewide grand jury.
Said Broward Schools Supt. Jim Notter: "I've built a 37-year career by being passionate about digging through the data, emphasizing accountability and getting things done right."
Sure. Except when he was willfully violating state law to allow the lobbyist and contractors to take over the school district and waste hundreds of millions in taxpayers' money.
Read the rest of the post at: http://blogs.browardpalmbeach.com/pulp/2011/02/beachside_village_montessori_gottlieb.php ----- South Florida Sun-Sentinel sun-sentinel.com/news/broward/fl-broward-schools-meeting222-20110223,0,5939659.story Notter vows to stay as superintendent of Broward schools Promises to address grand jury findings By Megan O'Matz and Cara Fitzpatrick, Sun Sentinel February 23, 2011
Broward Schools Superintendent Jim Notter vowed Tuesday to stay on the job despite being bashed in a grand jury report for allowing a self-serving School Board to use the district as a multi-billion dollar piggy bank for friends and cronies.
"I have no plans to resign or retire at this point in time," said Notter, who is in his fifth year as head of Broward Schools and who earns about $300,000 a year. However, he said he takes responsibility for the report's "devastating" findings and promised to regain the public's trust in him and the Board.
Notter was flanked by a majority of the Board at the hastily called news conference. "Yes, we do have confidence in the superintendent," said chairman Benjamin J. Williams, a board member since 2000.
Notter's comments followed Friday's release of the statewide grand jury report, which accused the School Board and senior management of "malfeasance." It concluded the level of mismanagement and ineptitude was so great it could only be attributed to widespread corruption.
The report portrayed a district run by individuals who directed contracts to friends, pushed unnecessary building projects, insisted on costly changes to construction projects, opened new schools before all safety measures were addressed, and paid contractors in full despite unfinished items.
The grand jury did not indict anyone, however, citing "weaknesses" in state law that make prosecution difficult and statutes that do not cover certain behavior that likely should be deemed criminal.
Notter said he and his staff will "go through this report point by point," and produce a detailed response to the public within 30 to 45 days.
Of the problems, he said: "We will fix it."
The grand jury took a year to investigate the district, prompted by the September 2009 arrest of then School Board member Beverly Gallagher for bribery. She was later convicted. Another one-time board member, Stephanie Kraft, has since been charged with bribery and is awaiting trial. She's pleaded not guilty.
In the past year, Notter said, the school system has implemented several reforms, some of which the grand jury also recommends.
Board members no longer sit on committees that select insurance companies, banks, construction firms and architects to do business with the district. A lobbyist registration policy was strengthened to include penalties. Ethics training was stepped up. And contractors are not given final payments until all inspections are complete and safety items addressed.
One of the grand jury's chief concerns was that schools were open with only "temporary" occupancy permits, signifying not all fire safety, plumbing, electrical and design items were addressed. Rather than fix the issues within the required 90-days, the district let matters rest for months and even years.
What's more, record-keeping was so poor that the grand jury said the number of projects still with temporary permits, or no occupancy documents, could be as high as 200, a figure it found "appalling."
Notter was at a loss to say how many school buildings still have unaddressed safety issues but promised to find the answers.
Outside of the news conference, the School Board carried on with its normal business during a day-long workshop, holding mannerly discussions on class size, building accessibility and budgets.
As customary at workshops, it did not take public comment.
The panel did, however, debate provisions of a proposed ethics policy that would restrict board members from accepting gifts over $50; bar them from serving on committees that select contractors and insurance providers; and force them to disclose outside work such as consulting agreements.
It would also require the district to maintain a record of each lobbyist visit to board members and would compel members to report each time they solicited funds for charities.
While the School Board insisted it wanted a strong ethics policy in place quickly, it sent the proposal back to staff for further revisions.
"Let's make it crystal clear to everybody so I don't have to ask my secretary what is proper and what is not," board member Maureen Dinnen said.
Of particular concern was a requirement that board members disclose when they solicit donations for charity. A few said they found it unnecessarily burdensome to have to report on their "mommy" activities such as raising money for their children's rugby teams or Girl Scout troops.
"I sold thousands of boxes of cookies," said Girl Scout troop leader and School Board member Robin Bartleman. "How can you make it so it's doable for us?"
During a break at Tuesday's workshop, School Board member Jennifer Gottlieb was mobbed by reporters questioning her involvement in the construction of Hollywood's Beachside Montessori school. The grand jury called it a $25 million "boondoggle," exemplifying "everything that is wrong with the Board and the District."
Shrinking enrollment did not justify building the new K-8 school there, the grand jury said, but the district pressed on, in part because it was Gottlieb's "baby." The report slammed the Board and administrators for allowing Gottlieb to "unilaterally shove through a pet project." Gottlieb's son attends the school.
On Tuesday, Gottlieb said plans for the school were under way before she was elected in 2006 and she had no hand in choosing the site or the contractor. She did, however, advocate it being switched from a regular curriculum to a Montessori approach, in which children learn at their own pace.
"I pushed for a program that was successful," Gottlieb said of the curriculum.
---- South Florida Sun-Sentinel sun-sentinel.com/news/columnists/fl-broward-schools-mayocol-b022411-20110223,0,4087127.column Can Broward School Board, Notter make things right? Public needs to demand answers, accountability Michael MayoSun Sentinel Columnist 7:34 PM EST, February 23, 2011
Broward Schools Superintendent Jim Notter calls himself "a data nut." He also calls himself "a form follows function nut," whatever that means.
So here was my data question to him after a scathing grand jury report: How many Broward schools are still operating with "temporary" certificates of occupancy, meaning they might not have passed final safety inspections?
"I do not have that data at this time," the Data Nut said at a Tuesday news conference.
Notter said the district has rehired a consultant to sort it out.
How reassuring.
"I understand that some parents might have concerns," Notter said. "I need to rebuild confidence."
It's more than a little disconcerting that the country's sixth-largest school district is so scattershot it doesn't have centralized building records. Especially with the umpteenth grand jury lambasting the district for its odd construction and inspection practices.
So maybe it's time for Notter to rebrand himself.
Maybe he should call himself a Reform Follows Dysfunction Nut.
That is, if Notter gets the chance at more reforms after another black eye for the school district.
Notter was in full damage-control mode on Tuesday, when he tried to stanch the wounds from the grand jury report.
He said he takes full responsibility, but won't step down. He said the district will have a point-by-point response … in 30-45 days (the better to let the hubbub die out?). He pointed to his post-Hurricane Wilma stewardship, even though a federal audit found the district didn't properly document how it spent millions in emergency grants.
Notter had eight of nine School Board members flank him in an apparent show of solidarity — new member Laurie Rich Levinson skipped out — but it's hard to say if he has long-term support.
"We need to give him the opportunity to respond," Levinson told me Wednesday. "But we do need to talk about a lot of things. There's some change that needs to be made internally, obviously … it's the staff in general, senior management people who have been here a long time."
Notter, a longtime district administrator, is in his fifth year as superintendent. That's about the time when many leaders reach their expiration date. Especially those who serve elected school boards looking for easy scapegoats during tough times.
Notter says he's not going anywhere. He vowed to stay and fix things.
The question is, can he be trusted to fix things?
Then again, can the School Board that would pick his successor be trusted either?
Four members are recent arrivals elected in November, but five are holdovers who collectively got scorched by the grand jury. When they weren't being called corrupt or meddlesome, they were being labeled wasteful and incompetent.
Ouch.
So who's going to save students, parents and taxpayers from this lot?
It's up to us. It's time to start caring, time to demand better answers and accountability.
Next Tuesday's regular board meeting, where public comment will be allowed, will be a good start.
The grand jury chided the School Board for allowing too many big decisions involving big bucks to be decided without proper public input, often stashing them in the "consent agenda" where items are voted upon in one fell swoop.
This Tuesday's all-day board workshop was a weird exercise in denial. After the grand jury report, you'd expect some outrage or at least some grandstanding by new board members.
But things were business as usual, and oh so polite. Except for Levinson, board members sat like willing movie extras when it came time for Notter's news conference.
New board member Dave Thomas had made comments to the Sun-Sentinel about a no-confidence vote, but it didn't happen. At the workshop, Thomas seemed more concerned about ditching a proposed tough new ethics policy.
Board members shrilly twisted the guidelines, making it seem as if harmless fundraising activities like selling Girl Scout cookies would get them in trouble. (All they would have to do under the proposed new rules is declare their activities on a form, and not pressure anyone into donating because of their position).
They'll continue working on the policy.
How tone-deaf can they be?
It's time for some outside voices to start chiming in. If you care about our schools and our kids' education, show up for the next School Board meeting Tuesday at 9:45 a.m., at district headquarters, 600 SE Third Ave., Fort Lauderdale.
Otherwise expect the same old sad song to play on.
The $25 million decision to construct a Montessori magnet school in Hollywood was easier to support before the school was built than it has been to defend since, Broward Schools Superintendent Jim Notter said Friday.
He said he stands by the decision, but in the wake of last week's blistering statewide grand jury report criticizing district leadership, he acknowledged it's a tougher sell in 2011 than it was in 2008.
"At the time, we felt it was an appropriate expense," he said. "In retrospect, could we have done things differently? That's always a possibility."
The district is still compiling its formal response to the grand jury report, with the Florida Department of Education expecting answers next week.
The report faults district leadership for failing to stop the construction of Beachside Montessori Village after changing enrollment figures made it clear the neighborhood didn't need a new school.
The grand jury called it "a microcosm of everything that's wrong with the board and district."
School Board member Jennifer Gottlieb, whose son attends the Hollywood magnet school, was portrayed, but not named, in the report as a meddling influence. She continued to insist this week she did nothing improper.
"If the school were empty and we had to hold enrollment drives to get people to apply, I could understand the criticism," she said.
The Broward State Attorney's Office is reviewing the 51-page report, including the six pages that deal with Montessori, to determine whether legal action will need to be taken.
By a number of standards, Gottlieb said, the magnet school is a success.
Still in its first year, it has a large and active parent teacher association, has conducted tours attended by 150 to 200 families interested in enrolling their children next year, and logged 700 applications last year in the first week they became available, Gottlieb said.
But critics have pointed to inequities in the school's population, including a high percentage of non-Hispanic whites (65 percent, compared to 30 percent in the district) and, according to Notter, a relatively low percentage of students on free and reduced lunch programs.
Admission was based in part on a random lottery, with slots set aside for children transferring from Virginia Shuman Young Elementary school in Fort Lauderdale, another Montessori school. Among those students were the children of Gottlieb and Hollywood Mayor Peter Bober. The school also gives preference to students enrolled in Montessori's pre-k programs, which cost $135 a week.
The grand jury report focused on the story behind the school's construction, steering clear of criticizing the school itself.
"…After 2006, Beachside became a particular board member's 'baby,'" the report states. "…It is well known to virtually all District employees that most, if not all, Board members have pet projects that it's best not to interfere with, no matter how wasteful or unjustifiable the project may appear to be."
Gottlieb challenged the report's characterization of her involvement.
"I did not 'meddle' in this project at all," she said. "The idea to build it was made before I was elected.''
She also said she was not responsible for making Beachside a K-8 school, a change from the original elementary school plan that necessitated delays and design changes and drove up the cost, according to the report. Specific figures weren't given.
When the new school building wasn't ready for the start of the 2010-11 school year, the district housed the Beachside Montessori magnet program at nearby Bethune Elementary and Attucks Middle schools.
"That proved you could have moved a Montessori school into the existing facilities without having to construct a new building," said Cliff Germano, secretary of the North Central Hollywood Civic Association.
When the new school was conceived, the neighborhood schools were overcrowded.
"It was supposed to benefit the local community," Germano said. "But by the time the board got ready to build the school, enrollment had dropped. Now the nearest schools were under capacity. But the board decided they were going to build it anyway."
That was against the wishes of then-Deputy Superintendent Michael Garretson, who tried to have the plug pulled on the project in 2008 only to run afoul of Gottlieb, according to the report. She "stated emphatically that the school would be built and it would be built with that contractor," the report states.
Gottlieb acknowledges continuing to support the school and Notter defended her role. "She never did anything inappropriate to influence or advocate for any decision that was not in the best interest of the children in the district," he said.
Gottlieb said the district had already purchased the land, exercising eminent domain to buy and demolish homes and duplexes [at a cost of $6 million, according to the report]. In that light, it made sense to change the plan from a neighborhood school to a magnet that would draw students from the southern half of the county, she said.
With a son in Fort Lauderdale's Virginia Shuman Young Montessori school, Gottlieb was familiar with the program and committed to replicating it elsewhere in Broward. The new school seemed an ideal site, she said.
But critics said she stood to benefit personally because students from Shuman Young who lived south of Interstate 595 would be automatically accepted into Beachside Montessori. Gottlieb's family lives in Hollywood.
Beachside Parent Teacher Association President Stephanie Sardelli said she would have brought her children to any Montessori school, whether at a new building, out in the western part of the county, or at Bethune and Attucks.
"I was happy at Bethune and Attucks," she said. "I don't think it matters where the program is located. It's a terrific educational model that deserved to be duplicated."
Wanted to be sure to bring this very thorough Megan O'Matz article from the Sun-Sentinel to your attention before I finally start posting some of the many photos (and video) that I shot last Tuesday night in Hollywood which Broward School members Ann Murray and (former Chair) Jennifer Gottlieb spoke at, while pretending that we couldn't see the whole disgraceful performance for what it was - a dog-and-pony show among acolytes. If anything, reading the O'Matz article a few times only underscores the genuine depth of outrage I've heard among both my own well-informed friends and the average Broward citizens I've seen and heard speak publicly on this matter, since the statewide Grand Jury revealed last Friday thathundreds of millions of dollars were likely squandered away in unnecessary school construction in this county.
South Florida Sun-Sentinel www.sun-sentinel.com/news/broward/fl-grand-jury0224-20110224,0,57428.story State demands answers from Broward Schools about grand jury report Notter given til March 2 to submit plan of action By Megan O'Matz, Sun Sentinel 8:38 PM EST, February 24, 2011
The Florida Department of Education is considering whether to launch its own probe of the Broward School District in light of a grand jury report accusing the School Board of "gross mismanagement."
In a letter Tuesday to School Board Chairman Benjamin Williams, Education Commissioner Eric J. Smith said that by law his agency's Office of Inspector General is required to investigate if the School Board is "unwilling or unable to address substantiated allegations made by any person relating to waste, fraud, or financial mismanagement within the school district."
The state asked that by March 2 the district submit a plan of action to address the grand jury's findings and recommendations. It should "include specific steps taken or planned,'' wrote Smith, who was not available for an interview Thursday.
Schools Superintendent Jim Notter said Williams will reply by March 2 with a "point by point" report of what's been done and what still needs to be done. Notter noted that the grand jury spent a year looking at the district, and he and the board would have liked more than a few days to prepare a response. On Tuesday, he had promised a response within 45 days.
The Statewide Grand Jury on Public Corruption concluded a year-long investigation of Broward schools this month and released a report last Friday saying the mismanagement and ineptitude were so pervasive it could only be explained by "corruption of our officials by contractors, vendors and their lobbyists."
The grand jury issued no indictments but said it regretted that, under the state constitution, it could not abolish the whole School Board.
By law, the Office of Inspector General can conduct, coordinate or request investigations into allegations of financial mismanagement across all 67 Florida school districts and the community colleges.
The office has the power to report to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement or other law enforcement agencies "whenever the inspector general has reasonable grounds to believe there has been a violation of criminal law," according to statute.
As the investigative arm of the grand jury, FDLE interviewed witnesses and gathered reams of documents related to the Broward School District.
The grand jury accused the School Board of steering work to favored contractors and consultants with little or no public discourse, pushing costly and unnecessary pet projects, opening new schools without the proper safety inspections and repairs, retaliating against whistleblowers, and failing to keep basic and crucial records.
Notter, who has overseen the district since late 2006, was harshly criticized for failing to curb the abuses.
Talmadge W. Fair, chairman of the state Board of Education, which is the policymaking body for all Florida school districts, said it would be unfair to comment before receiving Notter's official response.
"Due process must be allowed to run its course," he said, adding that he has not spoken to Notter but is "anxiously awaiting" his next steps.
Finding that the problems with the Broward Schools have been longstanding, the grand jury said it had no confidence the School Board would "make meaningful changes" and adhere to them.
It suggested the board be stripped of as much power as possible and "an independent outside authority" installed to monitor the district.
Fair said the state cannot appoint an overseer. "The local School Board has the power," he said.
Under the state constitution, Gov. Rick Scott can suspend School Board members and other elected officials for "malfeasance, misfeasance, neglect of duty, drunkenness, incompetence, permanent inability to perform official duties, or commission of a felony."
Scott's office has not returned repeated e-mails and calls seeking comment on what action, if any, he will take.
Former state Sen. Dan Gelber, a Miami Democrat who ran unsuccessfully for state Attorney General last year, thinks the Broward School Board is fully capable of instituting stronger integrity measures. Four of the nine board members were first elected in November.
"Often, in the wake of this kind of bad press, people take it as an opportunity to reform," he said.
"Often, in the wake of this kind of bad press, people take it as an opportunity to reform." Really? In South Florida? Hmm-m... when was that that exactly?
I have no experience of such a thing EVER happening here since my family relocated to South Florida in 1968, especially among a large group of elected officials who already stand convicted in the court of public opinion for being both incompetent and corrupt, and whose feeble and self-serving responses since the Grand Jury's final report came out is both underwhelming and insulting in the extreme, with Gottlieb and Murray leading that sorry parade. Yes, this rather queer and disconnected response of Dan Gelber's reminds me all over again why I made a point of writing in this space a few times last year about why I wouldn't be voting for him, in either the Democratic primary or in the general election, voting for Dave Aronberg and Pam Bondi, respectively, instead.
The most noteworthy of those reasons was Gelber's longstanding short-sightedness, in that despite all of his years of experience in politics, he STILL literally CAN'T see what the rest of us living in this area could seeabout many of his supporters among the Broward elected elite, and their highly questionable anti-democratic behavior and strange sense of ethics. For the life of me, at first, I couldn't understand why Megan O'Matz chose to ask Dan Gelber his opinion, but having done so, his tin-ear response not only reaffirms my relief that he was not elected Attorney General of the Sunshine State, but also made me realize that perhaps she was just being sly, in that Gelber talking about Notter's Crew was simply birds-of-a-feather. You see, who better to ask about a ridiculous situation where highly-paid people in charge didn't know what was going on and seemed to care not a whit about the consequences of that inaction than a guy like Dan Gelber, who acted at the time like there'd be no real consequences for moving the 2008 Florida presidential primary up to a date that the DNC specifically had forbidden and warned there'd be severe penalties. But he did it anyway, didn't he? Or perhaps unlike me, you've forgotten about his championing the idea of a "revote" that would cost millions of taxpayer dollars? Well, I haven't.
James Notter and Dan Gelber together again. But as usual, they're looking for others to pay for their indifference. Not to say I told you so, but I did. That's how they roll...
On subplot of Banksy's "Exit Through The Gift Shop," he himself says, "Maybe it should have been called ‘Don’t Bite the Hand that Feeds You.’” How can you not appreciate the wit and gall of a guy who turns the tables on someone so brilliantly? And that my friends is why there will be an infinitely larger number of people around the world than usual actually paying attention to who wins the Oscar for the Best Documentary at tonight's Academy Awards. http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/wireStory?id=13011445
Los Angeles Times Getting at the truth of 'Exit Through the Gift Shop' Thierry Guetta, the Oscar-nominated documentary's subject, says it's '100% real.' Public records support his biography, but questions persist about Banksy's role. By Jason Felch, Los Angeles Times February 22, 2011 http://theenvelope.latimes.com/news/la-et-oscar-exit-20110222,0,7905421.story Washington Postvideos by Jen Chaney: Mr. Brainwash on Banksy, Oscars and 'Exit Through the Gift Shop'
Related Washington Post article: Posted at 11:10 AM ET, 02/26/2011 Oscars 2011: Talking with Mr. Brainwash, aka Thierry Guetta of 'Exit Through the Gift Shop,' about Banksy and Oscar nightby Jen Chaney http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/video/2011/02/26/VI2011022601407.html This article appears at the WaPo's consistently reliable and amusing Celebritology blog, which I subscribe to thru my blog's Dashboard, a frequent topic of emails to friends.
Celebritology is light years ahead of anything the South Florida news media offers in the way of pop culture or sociological ponderings, the Herald in particular, which seems to think it's still 1995, judging by their truly dreadful content. http://voices.washingtonpost.com/celebritology/
Sorry, talking to dopey self-absorbed rappers and self-promoting chefs visiting South Beach is nobody's idea of serious or interesting cultural insight, high-brow or low-brow, yet they persist in constantly cranking it out when there are so many stories that should be appearing in print. IY'S EXASPERATING!
Plus, and this is the real sad lesson of how bad things are over there, too many of the Herald's "reporters" act more like publicists or wannabe PR consultants than they do journalists. Even worse, so many are sycophants for particular points-of view in South Florida that already over-represented, with more than enough people already speaking on their behalf.
Photos:Oscars: Banksy Does L.A. - ABC News Swedish TV's (Sveriges Television, SVT)take on the race for Best DocumentaryOscar: http://svt.se/2.150121/pgrp_januari_2011
SVT's fascinatingDocumentary homepage, whose newsletter I receive, and which even has films you can actually watch online: http://svt.se/2.118538/dokumentar
Exit Through the Gift Shop: http://www.banksyfilm.com/?utm_source=dailysugar&utm_medium=email&utm_term=20100416&utm_content=email_link&utm_campaign=dailysugar_email_20100416
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/14/movies/14banksy.html New York Times April 14, 2010 Riddle? Yes. Enigma? Sure. Documentary? By Melina Ryzik
Is there an art-world equivalent of crying wolf? If so, Banksy has probably done it.
Banksy, the pseudonymous British street artist, has built his reputation on stunts — like inserting his own work among the masters’ in museums — that taunted the market in which his pieces sold for millions. But with his latest project, the documentary “Exit Through the Gift Shop,” he is laboring to convince audiences that he’s playing it straight.
The film, which opens on Friday in New York and California, follows Thierry Guetta, an amiable Frenchman who lives in Los Angeles and videotapes everything — or so we’re told. When Mr. Guetta and camera eventually tunnel into the world of street art — he was introduced to the scene through a cousin, the Parisian artist Space Invader — his enthusiastic recording melds nicely with the artists’ desire to have their otherwise ephemeral work documented. He captures that scene’s luminaries, like Shepard Fairey and Swoon working on rooftops and in alleys under cover of night.
It seems to be a natural fit for a documentary. But Mr. Guetta’s nonstop footage turns out to be unwatched (he has boxes and boxes of unlabeled tapes) and even when he cobbles something together after years of shooting, largely unwatchable. “He was maybe just somebody with mental problems who happened to have a camera,” Banksy says in the film.
So Banksy decides to take control of the material himself — or so we’re told. Robbed of his camera and prodded by Banksy, Mr. Guetta, meanwhile, morphs into a street artist, inventing an alter ego called Mr. Brainwash and staging an opening exhibition in Los Angeles that turns him into an overnight sensation, all of which is captured in “Exit Through the Gift Shop.”
The film itself was a sensation at the Sundance Film Festival this year, especially after Banksy works (including stenciled images of a cameraman shooting a flower) began popping up on storefront walls in Park City, Utah. At the Berlin International Film Festival in February, he called a news conference, only to cancel it at the last minute and show a video, in which he appears in shadows, cloaked in a hoodie and with his voice disguised, as he does in the film, to vouch for its veracity.
The thing is, both Banksy and Mr. Guetta are pretty unreliable narrators. The immediate scuttlebutt was that Mr. Guetta either didn’t exist at all, that he was in cahoots with Banksy or that he was Banksy himself. Even aficionados of the scene were unsure what to think.
“Is it real?” asked Andrew Michael Ford, the director of the Last Rites Gallery in New York and an independent curator who has worked with street artists. “Is it a hoax?” The film, he added, offered so many circular possibilities that it was “tough to comment on it directly.”
But everyone involved has vouched for it. “Of course the more I try to say it’s all true, the more it sounds like I’m somehow perpetuating the conspiracy,” said Mr. Fairey, a friend of Banksy’s.
Mr. Guetta did not respond to a request for comment — though he does seem to exist and to be as idiosyncratic as he is in the film.
“I don’t know why so many people have been fooled into thinking this film is fake,” Banksy, or someone purporting to be he, wrote in an e-mail message from Los Angeles, where the film had a premiere on Monday night. “It’s a true story from real footage. Does it bother me people don’t believe it? I could never have written a script this funny.”
As Marc Schiller, the proprietor of the street-art-enthusiast Web site woostercollective.com, put it, “It is one of these cases where Banksy has found in his art that truth is stranger than the best fiction you can imagine.”
Both Mr. Schiller and Mr. Fairey said that “Exit Through the Gift Shop” was of a piece with Banksy’s site-specific work, like a guerilla Guantรกnamo installation at Disneyland and an ersatz pet store in the West Village.
“Banksy is making a movie that’s 100 percent like a Banksy exhibition,” Mr. Schiller said. He called it a prank, then corrected himself, labeling it “a Banksy event.”
Mr. Fairey, who said that he and Banksy were in the same situation in trying to recover the footage of their career-defining moments from Mr. Guetta, added: “This is a way for Banksy to tell his story but at the same time critique the street art phenomenon. It’s perfectly aligned with how he does things. But it was a very shrewd adaptation to a problem that existed, not something premeditated.”
Banksy said it was a stretch to call the film his directorial debut.
“I didn’t take the director’s credit because I thought that was a bit unfair,” he wrote. “The editors essentially built the whole thing, and I deferred to the producer on the scenes I feature in — otherwise I’d just have picked the shots where my silhouette looks good.”
Still, he added, making it was “an all-consuming process, and my vandalism has certainly suffered as a result.” And Mr. Schiller said that Banksy was “involved in the smallest little detail of every aspect of this production and of the marketing of the film.” (Banksy said he financed it himself; new graffiti appeared in Los Angeles for the premiere.)
The surprise, Mr. Ford said, is in how quickly non-art-world audiences were to accept the notion of graffiti as a major spectacle.
“It’s one of those things where I’m not quite sure what I’m here for, but I’m excited about it,” a fan in line for Mr. Brainwash’s 2008 show, where works sold for tens of thousands — still far less than Banksy’s prices — says in the film.
“Banksy cares very much about selling art and what people think of him,” Mr. Fairey said, “and he understands thoroughly that people’s fantasy is a far better marketing tool than reality.”
Ultimately, wondering whether “Exit Through the Gift Shop” is real or not may be moot. It certainly asks real questions: about the value of authenticity, financially and aesthetically; about what it means to be a superstar in a subculture built on shunning the mainstream; about how sensibly that culture judges, and monetizes, talent.
Asked whether a film that takes shots at the commercialization of street art would devalue his own work, Banksy wrote: “It seemed fitting that a film questioning the art world was paid for with proceeds directly from the art world. Maybe it should have been called ‘Don’t Bite the Hand that Feeds You.’ ”
Banksy's Bristol showcase from June of 2009 http://www.channel4.com/news/articles/watchlisten/gallery/banksys+bristol+showcase/3208362.html
On an appearance on KTLA-TV(Los Angeles), Adam Carolla channels Sheridan Whiteside and skewers the American media's strange love affair with newCNN chat host Piers Morgan, and slams the narcisissm running rampant in the U.S., giving numerous examples of things that bother him. Now that's funny -and true! The best of all posssible worlds!
Adam's podcast, available for free, is currently the most-popular podcast on iTunes. He'll be appearing at the South Beach Comedy Festival next Thursday the 3rd at the Colony Theater on Miami Beach and up at the West Palm Improv on Friday March 4th. http://www.ticketmaster.com/event/0D00462AE2E06E5F http://www.adamcarolla.com/ACPBlog/
http://www.ktla.com/
The Man Who Came To Dinner, with Monty Woolley as Sheridan Whiteside, only one of my ten favorite films -and literary characters- ever.
Above, a video showing a side of American pop culture that you'd think the South Florida news media would've already shown over-and-over by now.
In any case, seeing it puts me in the mood to recall a thing or two I once wrote in 2009 about Marco Rubio, back when the South Florida news media had all but conceded the 2010 GOP U.S. Senate nomination to Charlie Crist.
But some of us could see that what was so appealing about him to us would also prove just as appealing with Florida voters, confounding the "experts" who discounted his talk about taking the Constitution seriously. The excerpt below is from a June 22nd, 2009 email to a Hallandale Beach friend who'd first told me weeks before about the underdog Rubio's appearance that June night in Hallandale Beach, which took place before an overflow audience at the Hallandale Beach Cultural Center.
All of my photos below are from June 22, 2009, Hallandale Beach.
That's Anthony Man of the South Florida Sun-Sentinel at the table.
-----
As I said earlier, if I don't get that info from you tonight, I'll write the basics about his appearance at the HB Cultural Center Tuesday night, and try to post it before I go to sleep tonight.
I may(?) also post the clueless Beth Reinhard column from Saturday's Herald that was one of the worst of the many bad columns she's penned since I returned to South Florida:
http://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/columnists/story/1105950.html She's truly awful and bereft of either insight or originality.
But by embracing DeMint, Rubio risks moving too far to the right. DeMint advocates sending illegal immigrants back to their home countries and making English the official language of the United States, which could mean that Rubio's Spanish-speaking constituents would not be able to get ballots and other government documents in their first language.
I'm going to be picking that column apart soon on my blog, as it is full not only of intellectual laziness, but factual errors, not the least of which is the comments about the language of the ballots, since the DOJ has oversight over certain states because of the federal Voting Rights Act, and that includes Florida.
You know, where we live?
Plus, because South Florida's county officials have decided that it's good public policy that ballots also appear in Spanish (and Creole), and that is supported by the majority of the local populace, Reinhard's argument is a straw man.
A good reporter would already know that.
That Beth Reinhard doesn't, or acts like she doesn't, gives you some true sense of her profound political ignorance.
Not that this is exactly Breaking News to me.
Frankly, I almost always groan after reading something Reinhard's written.
In fact, it was after reading some nonsense she'd written about Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, while I was having breakfast with my father at Denny's, that I decided I needed to finally listen to my friends back in D.C., who'd been urging me for years to start a blog when I was still livingthere.
Right, when all my media and political connections were close-at-hand and would've proved very useful to me in sharing some very interesting stories, anecdotes and insight that I was either eyewitness to or privy to, that had heretofore remained the domain of party chatter among very close friends with a curiosity matching mine.
10:35 p.m. Just got your new email with attendee info. Thanks!
Confirmed Speakers: RNC Secretary Sharon Day, Broward GOP Chairman Chip LaMarca, Marco Rubio Candidate for US Senate, Lt. Col. Allen West Candidate for US Congress, Joyce Kaufman 850 AM Radio Host, and a special video presentation from Michael Steele.Performing our National Anthem, National Vocalist Lou Galterio.
This Matthew Ingram piece is an excellent analysis of the changing media landscape, and the legacy media's attempt to freeze things in place to maintain their old advantages.
Sometimes, even when that old media is, in fact, a popular website or blog itself, like Deadline Hollywood, Nikki Finke's site that I've had on my blog roll since I started this humble blog of mine just over four years ago.
In general, those efforts as such aren't working as American news consumers continue voting with their feet -and eyeballs- to get more and better written information with unique content.
And to bring this issue to a local level, it doesn't help when the majority of South Florida's mainstream media is risk-averse, seemingly wanting stories either nice-and-neat when they deign to show-up somewhere, or, delivered to them like hotel room service over the telephone, without the reporter ever leaving his or her desk. Worst of all, most of them DON'T and WON'T show-up at public events that are clearly newsworthy, a noticeable fact very much on the minds of people like myself, who actually DOSHOW-UP at government meetings and public policy forums in South Florida.
gigaom.com You Can’t Play a New Media Game By Old Media Rules By Mathew Ingram Feb. 24, 2011, 9:02am PT
If there’s one aspect of the media business that has been disrupted more completely than any other, it’s the whole idea of “breaking news.” Just as television devalued the old front-page newspaper scoop, the web has turned breaking news into something that lasts a matter of minutes — or even seconds — rather than hours. If your business is to break news, your job is becoming harder and harder every day...
Thus far, which is to say about 10 p.m. on Thursday the 24th, I've been unable to ascertain the exact location of where the protests described in this article below will take place in South Florida on Saturday.
I will be calling State Sen. Rene Garcia's office on Friday to find out if they know any particulars that would be helpful to know. His district office phone number is (305) 364-3100
In the absence of an organized event closer to many of us here in this part of southeast Broward County, it would seem common sense to me that the eastern sidewalk along U.S.-1, south of Hallandale Beach -right near the first red-light camera erected in Hallandale Beach- would seem the best location for such an event.
It also offers a highly-visible location with an infinite supply of people driving by who will be in support of repealing the current red-light camera law, which, sadly for residents of Hallandale Beach, the city is clearly exploiting for revenue purposes.
And when you think about it, is there really a red-light camera location in South Florida more infamous than this one? In a word, "NO!" As you know from my previous posts here, and some very fair-minded articles in the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, the Broward County Commission will be voting on Tuesday on the issue of the current law being repealed by the Florida legislature.
The bill in the State House to repeal is Bill 4087, which was filed by State Rep. Richard Corcoran, R-New Port Richey, and the companion in the State Senate is Senate Bill 672, filed bySen. Garcia, whose district is based out of Hialeah.
See also: Report Critiques Red Light Camera Research Methods University of South Florida analysis elaborates on conclusion that red light cameras are associated with increased injury accidents. http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/34/3413.asp WBAL-TV I-Team video: Dead Officer Signed Red Light Citations Baltimore Police, Other Officials Work To Correct Problem POSTED: 1:30 pm EST February 10, 2011 http://www.wbaltv.com/news/26821379/detail.html
The Washington Post How red-light cameras work http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/02/22/AR2011022206911.html
Ed Smith Stadium Poised to Be a Jewel http://link.brightcove.com/services/player/bcpid294377117?bctid=801143657001
Orioles' newly-refurbished spring training facility in Sarasota, Ed Smith Stadium, set to open Tuesday vs. Tampa Rays, and news media got first chance to see insideon Wednesday. http://baltimore.orioles.mlb.com/spring_training/ballpark.jsp?c_id=bal
I knew if I kept looking, somebody would finally have video of what they've done to change a stadium that had really seen its best days. I missed this on The Fan on Tuesday but caught up via the digital wonderland that is the Internet: Former Director of Minor League Operations for the Orioles, Doc Rodgers spoke The Fan's Bruce and Bob about realistic expectations for the Orioles 2011 season and what to look for during spring training. http://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2011/02/23/a-look-at-the-birds-in-sarasota/ Listen LIVE to 105.7 The Fan, Baltimore http://player.radio.com/player/RadioPlayer.php?version=1.2.10916&station=115
See also: Baltimore Orioles official homepage: http://baltimore.orioles.mlb.com/index.jsp?c_id=bal
Baltimore Sun's O Zonehomepage: http://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/orioles/
Orioles homepage at MASN website: http://www.masnsports.com/index_orioles.php
Jen Royle Royle's Rundown: http://www.masnsports.com/the_royle_rundown/
