Showing posts with label historic preservation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label historic preservation. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 14, 2022

The very dangerous precedent for the future that the Hollywood and Miami Beach City Commissions are making by showing thru both word and deed, that their own land use ordinances mean nothing when The Related Group comes calling


Residents and stakeholders of #HollywoodFL and #MiamiBeach are quite rightfully fearful of the very dangerous precedents their two respective City Commissions are clearly making by showing thru both words and deeds, that their own land use ordinances mean nothing when The Related Group comes calling. 

Mean nothing, that is, IF there are deep-pocketed real estate developers interested in doing something the clear majority of the community is opposed to, but the firm is willing to ignore existing public sentiment against it because they have the resources not to care about the optics to others of ignoring the community's desires.

I've been meaning for the last few months to share my thoughts regarding this New York Times story by former Miami Herald reporter Patricia Mazzei, at bottom, involving The Deauville Hotel, 

The Deauville is a historic Miami Beach property and also is one that I had occasion to go to several times over the years while growing-up in South Florida from 1968-1979, before I left for college and the cream and crimson of Indiana University, Bloomington.

I hasten to add, in my case, I was always going to The Deauville to see people visiting from out-of-town, NOT to stay overnight and make myself known to room service. 

For me at least, the story on The Deauville, below, serves as a timely reminder that the worst thing about The Related Group's incompatible plan for 1301 S. Ocean Drive on Hollywood Beach isn't merely that Mayor Josh Levy's snarky, passive-aggressive, and decidedly anti-transparent approach led to approximately ZERO of the REQUIRED public in-person COMMUNITY meetings taking place. either before (or since) the first public Hollywood City Commission meeting, when the Hollywood public was NOT even allowed inside Hollywood City Hall to directly confront the very people trying to change the charm and ambiance of that part of Hollywood Beach. The most natural part of Hollywood Beach that remains..

FTszzsgXsAIZdpW.jpg

Nor was it even the City's thin-skinned Communications Dept. peevishly and repeatedly attacking and demeaning people like my friend, Cat Uden and I online in our individual efforts to let the larger Hollywood and South Florida community know via the South Florida news media what was REALLY taking place. 

That includes the continuing lack of good faith the City's elected officials had shown Hollywood's citizens and stakeholders, whom THEY work for.

As it happens, Cat and I both have strong backbones and thick skins, plus, we have the advantage of having the facts on our side, and if you didn't already know it, the City's elected officials and Communications Dept. really, really hate... facts.
So this discrepancy, this ability to use their own information against them, really burns them, as does our success in getting the facts out to the larger public and the local, state and national news media.
Especially self-evident facts that can be wholly substantiated by both contemporaneous photographs and video.

No, it's not even the fact that supposed nature-lover, water sports-loving Josh Levy would, if successful, destroy, FOREVER, for nothing more than money, a place with a certain and unique ambiance that the community places a very high value on maintaining for future generations - THE most natural part of Hollywood Beach.
FSLP8uDX0AA-Uw3.jpg 
vs.
 FTszzsgWUAE4Abf.jpg

It isn't even that both proposed projects are -coincidentally- the handiwork of The Related Group. That almost was predictable, given the landscape of real estate development in Florida in 2022.

No, what's the worst thing of all in the case of the Hollywood Beach project is the terrible precedent it sets for the future, since it would likely set in motion a constant game of musical chairs on the beach, as local Mom and Pop hospitality businesses owning smaller properties decide that if the city's elected officials are publicly declaring by both their words and their deeds that the city's own rules and ordinances don't mean anything -since Related wants to build a luxury condo tower there for multi-millionaires that's 5-7x's larger than what's currently allowed on that part of the beach- why should they stay on the sidelines and be played for suckers?

If you understand anything at all about human behavior and how things have traditionally operated in South Florida when it comes to real estate, then you know that I'm right.
The reason is simple.
Because, suddenly, as a result of what Hollywood City Hall will have done, there will be no incentive at all for the smaller and successful property owners to invest more of their money and time to improve their current low-scale site.
They'll simply wait the neighborhood out until someone comes in with such a huge offer for their property that they decide to seell.

When that happens, goodbye Hollywood Beach ambiance and charm.
Forever.


If you didn't know it or may've forgotten it, The Deauville is where The Beatles, famously,  stayed and performed in February of 1964 on CBS-TV's Sunday night blockbuster, The Ed Sullivan Show: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEzPROIIlk4

One last thing, and it's a sign of the times about journalism as it's practiced in South Florida these days. You know what I could not find?

A single local story where Cuban-American Alex Meruelo, owner of the Meruelo Group, the owner of The Deauville, was/is actually asked why he allowed the property to become so run-down that it was deemed unsafe by the City of Miami Beach. 
How do you explain that?
Exactly.
"Today, the Deauville is shuttered, enclosed by an ugly chain-link fence. Soon, it is likely to be demolished. Preservationists fear the hotel’s slow demise will set a troubling precedent in their efforts to protect South Florida’s history."


 

Miami Beach owes its iconic status in no small part to the preservation of its Art Deco district, known the world over for the string of pastel-colored boutique hotels. But it has not always been easy to preserve buildings elsewhere in South Florida.
In its heyday, the Deauville Hotel in Miami Beach hosted the likes of The Beatles, Sammy Davis Jr. and President John F. Kennedy. Soon, the hotel is likely to be demolished, which historic preservationists fear will set a troubling precedent.
“Miami is a place where the land has always been more valuable than the building...There’s no shared history, and when you have no shared history and no shared culture, you have no shared commitment to maintaining that history or that culture.”
"The four-acre property, valued some years ago at $100 million, is owned by a corporate entity registered to the Meruelo family, which runs other hotels and casinos and also works in construction."

New York Times
A Grand Miami Beach Hotel, and Its History, Might Be Torn Down.
The Deauville Beach Resort played host to the Beatles, Frank Sinatra and John F. Kennedy. But it has been deemed unsafe after years of neglect.
By Patricia Mazzei
Published Jan. 17, 2022, Updated Jan. 20, 2022


FYI: "In the event of a total demolition, Miami Beach would be legally entitled to limit future construction to the Deauville’s same size."

Posted by at No comments:
Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, February 20, 2020

#HollywoodFL civic activists and Historic Preservation advocates are on the warpath. Feel betrayed by Hollywood officials after the 95-year old Great Southern Hotel is demolished without any public notice. To many Hollywood residents, city's decision seems awfully "convenient," given the widespread dissatisfaction with developer and the glacial pace of construction on Block 40



Once Upon a Time... 

 I attended last Tuesday afternoon's City of Hollywood Historic Preservation Board meeting at Hollywood City Hall at 3:00 pm, walking into the Commission Chambers a minute or two after it started because I had looked -in vain- out in the lobby for a written copy of the agenda to peruse.
I had so many things on my mind that I had left the house for the meeting before checking the city's website to see if that pertinent info was there.

 I say that because with no agenda available in the lobby, I and most of the public in the room got completely blindsided when, after some long and heated discussions about some proposed changes  to two city residential properties -including a beautiful house on N. Southlake Drive that last sold for $12.5 million- the dumbfounding news that was spoken aloud sometime after 4:15 pm about the demolition that very morning of the historic Great Southern Hotel, in the city's historic Downtown area, located on Block 40, directly across the street from the west side of Young Circle.
A building constructed in 1924 during Hollywood's infancy.

 And, a building that I have personally taken DOZENS of photos of over the past 16 years since I returned to South Florida from Washington, D.C. to look after my late Dad, following his quadruple heart operation.
And then later, following his Stroke in 2010. 😔😔

What little that was left of the actual Great Southern Hotel, the facades that were supposed to be incorporated into real estate developer Charles R. "Chip" Abele's project, were demolished specifically at the urging of City of Hollywood Chief Building Dept. head Dean Decker because of his and his Dept's "safety" concerns.
Yes, when you say "safety," you'd be surprised what usual procedures. protocols, and seats of power and responsibility seemingly don't apply.

 Maybe you'd even be surprised to find out that, as was stated obliquely at the Hollywood Historic Preservation Board meeting, the city's Building Dept., if they use the magic words "public safety," seemingly has the unfettered power to do things that even the elected Hollywood City Commission can not legally countermand.
Like the Building Dept.'s demolition order, something that other stakeholders in the city can not contest or at least take to court because the whole reason things were done the way they were Tuesday was to prevent interest groups from finding out and getting involved in a legal fashion.
@SFBJRealEstate MT @Susannah_Bryan Landmark #HollywoodFL hotel built in 1924 was leveled today. Developer #ChipAbele says he cld not save it despite earlier promises to do so.
Here’s my last story on the plans to bring a new project to downtown ⁦@cohgov. https://t.co/tjqPs7Lb2o

— HallandaleBeach/Hollywood Blog (@hbbtruth) February 11, 2020


Earlier in the day Decker had urged developer Chip Abele via a letter written earlier today to demolish it ASAP, and he explained his reasoning for the decision. 

 My September 21st, 2016 blog post with info and context about Abele and his company getting approval from the Hollywood City Commission for his Block 40 project is here:

Hollywood developer Chip Abele's years-long effort to launch #YoungCircleCommons project in Downtown Hollywood, across from The ArtsPark, w/a #HiltonHotel, clears hurdle as Hollywood City Comm. unanimously approves requested changes
https://hallandalebeachblog.blogspot.com/2016/09/hollywood-developer-chip-abeles-years.html 

It's been a long road for Abele, often the subject of biting criticism by the public at myriad meetings held at Hollywood City Hall and at various civic association meetings throughout the city that I've personally attended, both before and after I left Hollywood for 9-10 months to travel in August of 2018
That would include the Civic Associations here in the city for Hollywood Lakes, Park East, Hollywood Hills, North Central, the Downtown, Parkside, Royal Poinciana one, to say nothing of the one known as United Neighbors. I go to 4 or 5 of these a month, though some conflict with one another.

Back in 2008 our friends over at the South Florida Business Journal were writing,
Great Southern Hotel developer plans to move ahead in Chapter 11
The redeveloper of Hollywood's Great Southern Hotel, which has stood up to hurricanes, rancorous litigation and the housing meltdown, says it will continue to pursue the project as it works through Chapter 11.
Coral Gables-based SFD@Hollywood LLC filed for Chapter 11 reorganization bankruptcy on Tuesday. The filing attorney was Thomas M. Messana of Fort Lauderdale-based Messana Weinstein & Stern, P.A.
In an e-mail Thursday, Messana said the filing followed a failure to resolve a dispute over the delivery of 25,000 square feet of retail space on the ground floor of the proposed building.
SFD will pursue strategic alternatives on the project, but still intends to develop Youngs Circle Commons, the e-mail said.
Charles R. "Chip" Abele signed the filing as managing member of the limited liability corporation. Other managing members listed in state records are Jose R. Boschetti and Maurice Cayon.
The project called for restoring portions of the Great Southern with 19 stories of mixed-used space that would include 239 condominiums, 25,000 square feet of retail and a parking garage.
Assets and liabilities are each listed as totaling between $1 million and $10 million. Unsecured creditors range anywhere from $89,797 due to Broward County for 2007 property taxes to a $42.46 charge owed to Miami-based 60-Minute Courier.
A 2007 suit was heard in the 4th District Court of Appeal, with Friends of the Great Southern claiming that the city of Hollywood had violated its own building code by approving the partial demolition of the Great Southern Hotel. Directors of Friends of the Great Southern were Richard Vest, William Young and Rene Tewksbury. The city prevailed in the suit.


Earlier in 2008, there was this news in the Sun-Sentinel re the eminenet domain lawsuit between the city and the Mach family that owned the property on the southwest corner of Harrison and S. 19th Avenue, that has looked like this for years



Eminent domain ruling reversed
Ihosvani Rodriguez Staff WriterSouth Florida Sun-Sentinel
March 27, 2008
A state appeals court has decided to support the city's controversial attempt to take a family's downtown property and use it for private development.

The Fourth District Court of Appeal ruled 3-0 to overturn a Broward judge's 2006 ruling that said the city cannot take the Mach family's business property and give it to a powerful developer, according to the decision released Wednesday.

The Mach family has owned the 2,900-square-foot building on Harrison Street since 1972. The building houses the family's hair salon and several other businesses.

The city's downtown Community Redevelopment Agency has been fighting since 2005 to use eminent domain to obtain the property and transfer it to developer Charles "Chip" Abele for a $100 million project, a 19-story condo and retail tower called Young Circle Commons.

"This is very disappointing, obviously," said family spokesman David Mach, "but there's a 99 percent probability we will be appealing."

The Machs could ask the appeals court to reconsider, or, try to take the case to the Florida Supreme Court.

The appeals court panel ruled that Broward Circuit Judge Ronald J. Rothschild should have deferred to the redevelopment agency's 2005 finding that the property is vital to downtown redevelopment plans. Instead, he ruled that testimony during a 2006 trial showed the city and Abele didn't need the building to complete the project.

Attorneys for the city argued the land would be used as part of a traffic flow plan that would enable the developer to preserve the facade of the 1920s-era Great Southern Hotel as part of the Young Circle Commons project.

Such historic preservation is an acceptable reason for government to take private property through the process of eminent domain, the appeals court said in its ruling.

The abandoned hotel, now owned by Abele, is immediately north of the Mach building on Harrison Street. Development planners said the only viable place to build an entrance to the tower's garage is on 19th Avenue. But that would require razing the hotel's western wall-or, building the entrance farther south, on Mach's property.

Appeals court Associate Judge Lisa Davidson, who voted with the majority, said the city should take no more than the 17 feet Abele said he needs for the 30-foot-wide garage entrance.

The Florida Legislature in 2006 prohibited cities from using eminent domain for private redevelopment. But the new law doesn't apply to the Mach case because the city had already started eminent domain proceedings.

The city promised Abele in 2004 that if the developer could not buy out the Machs, it would take the building via eminent domain. Under the agreement, the city will purchase the Mach property through eminent domain and Abele will reimburse the city.

Redevelopment director Neil Fritz said in a statement Wednesday that Hollywood intends to "live up" to the deal with Abele. If the "appeals court decision prevails, we would ultimately transfer the property to the developer to allow the project to be built."

Abele has said he once offered the Machs $1.2 million, but they refused. On Wednesday he acknowledged the housing market is in the doldrums, but said he still wants to move forward with his plans.

"The window of opportunity to build condos has been shut until the markets recover," said Abele, "but this doesn't mean the project won't be built some day."

Mach said Wednesday he is optimistic the city commission, which doubles as the redevelopment agency's board, will back off.

"I have some faith in the new Hollywood government that they will do the right thing and protect the rights of its citizens," he said.


Reminder: Abele and his company also did the 25-story Hollywood Circle condo and retail project on Block 55 that now includes the new-ish Publix Supermarket, The Circ Hotel and its various restauarants, plus ground floor retail on the block northeast of Young Circle.

City Attorney Douglas R. Gonzales also spoke at great length at the Historic Preservation Board meeting chaired by my friend, Hollywood Lakes Civic Association President Terry Cantrell, one of the most involved and best-connected person in the city.

To say the least, most of the asembled public did not quite believe what they were hearing, even if they already knew what had taken place hours before.

Frankly, if I'd known the subject of the Great Southern Hotel was going to come up, I'd have brought my camera tripod with me to film the whole discussion, as I have hundreds of times over the years in Hollywood and Hallandale Beach, and then placed the video here on the blog for you to draw your own conclusions, after reading my thoughts.

 Why film it? 
Because those Hollywood Historic Preservation Board meetings are neither televised or recorded for the public to watch or review.

My own sense of things, based not only on what I observed during the meeting and immediately afterwards out in the lobby, when several people I know were very upfront and vocal with their criticisms of the city's decision, right to Decker's face, as well as what I've heard/received via emails and text messages is the following.
The smartest, most-involved, and most socially-adept #HollywoodFL civic activists I know and respect are... on the warpath against the city and its elected officials because they see this decision as a very personal betrayal. 
In an election year.

 They are irate about this matter for many reasons but if I had to narrow it down to two, I'd say that it's because, to them, it seems more than a bit "convenient" that this 95-year old building has been demolished:
a.) on the same day that Hollywood city official contacted the owner, and, 
b.) on the very same day the city of Hollywood posted this information to the city's website:

 Update on Block 40 Construction in Downtown Hollywood
https://hollywoodfl.org/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=728

 Posted on: February 11, 2020

Update on Block 40 Construction in Downtown Hollywood

Block 40 update
In late January, as construction crews were performing work to brace the portions of the former Great Southern Hotel to be preserved, the crews and on-site engineers observed issues with the structural integrity of the building, and notified the City of these concerns. The City’s Building Division reviewed reports from four different engineers and field inspections. The preponderance of evidence found significant deterioration of the structure or structural parts making the building unsafe per section 116.2.1.2.2 of the Florida Building Code. Due to the determination that the historic north and west facades of the former hotel were unsafe and posed a significant threat to public safety, a modification of the existing demolition permit was issued this morning and demolition of the unsafe structure was completed earlier this afternoon.
The City consulted with an Engineering firm that inspected the building, interviewed on-site construction contractors, reviewed all prior engineering reports and conducted strength testing of the building’s structural components. The concrete masonry of the former hotel was found to be in disrepair with core drilling tests yielding compression rates of 1320 to 1580 PSI. For commercial structures, 3000 PSI is the minimum requirement. The level of deterioration necessitated immediate attention to address a severe life safety hazard. The perimeter of the construction site was secured to allow for the demolition of the remaining structure.
In 2012, the City of Hollywood approved plans for the redevelopment of the site of the former Great Southern Hotel at the southwest corner of Hollywood Boulevard and Young Circle. The redevelopment plan is for a 19-story, mixed-use development with 166 upscale residential units and a 103 room hotel along with a restaurant and approximately 9,793 SF of retail and office space. The approved plans preserved and incorporated the north and west facades of the former Great Southern Hotel, originally constructed in the 1920s, as well as some interior features.
The development team has informed the City that they are committed to reconstructing the historical elements previously planned to be preserved as shown in the approved designs. They have also worked to save elements from the original construction with the goal of incorporating them into the new building where feasible.

Great Southern Hotel, Hollywood, Florida 
Uploaded June 28, 2012 by Dan Watson YouTube Channel
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJp2KTDPhT8&feature=youtu.be
-----



See also the rueful comments of my friend Lynn Smith, the President of the Downtown Parkside Royal Poinciana Civic Association, from whom I received the following excerpt of a letter last Friday.


Downtown Parkside Royal Poinciana Civic Association
P.O. Box 223697, 
Hollywood, FL 33022
https://www.facebook.com/DPRPCA/

 -----
Dave
David B. Smith


Hallandale Beach/Hollywood Blog: http://www.hallandalebeachblog.blogspot.com/ 
Posted by at No comments:
Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)