My comments follow the articles.----------
Miami Heraldhttp://www.miamiherald.com/news/broward/story/1192203.htmlBroward schools chief keeps his job through 2014By Patricia Mazzei
August 19, 2009
The Broward School Board unanimously extended Superintendent Jim Notter's contract by three years Tuesday following an annual evaluation that praised the schools chief.
Notter's contract was extended until June 2014, with a possibility of a further extension until 2015. It does not come with a raise unless other district staff members also get one -- something not in the plans this year.
"We're being responsible and doing what's right,'' School Board member Ann Murray said. "We have confidence in what he's doing.''
Notter, who is paid $299,000 a year, voluntarily cut $26,000 from his compensation last month. He was appointed superintendent in 2007.
Reader comments at:
----------
Going into Tuesday, of the many people in South Florida-far too many!- whose perennial sub par performanceDIDN'T merit having their contracts renewed -whilethey still had time left on them to prove their worth-the two most obvious were U-M head football coachRandy Shannon and Broward School Supt. JamesNotter.Both have gotten to their present post thru the insider'sroute and both are examples to me of the South Florida version of the Peter Principle, Banana Republic 2.0.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_PrincipleThat's the stealth version that's employed when newsreporters, TV cameras and the well-informed publicaren't around to see what's really going on, and askingtheir pesky questions.
And now we read that after Ann Murray's beenlargely invisible to her constituents for months,as I wrote about just the other day, she's nowsuddenly the one who singing James Notter'spraises after his contract was renewed unanimously?
What am I missing, exactly?
Murray ran on a platform last summer of changingthings dramatically at the Broward School Board, and not becoming a compliant clone of the existingmembers and the pervasive culture of corruptionand cronyism that's made the system a cesspooland laughingstock.After emailing this article to a well-informed Browardfriend who WAS a self-admitted 'strong' Murraysupporter, they replied simply, "Invasion of theBody Snatchers."
Now even Murray's most-fervent supporters arestarting to realize know that her performance on heraudition does NOT bode well for her re-electionprospects next year, as well it shouldn't.
If she'd actually done what she promised, Murray'sname ought to be the one that's on the tip of Browardtaxpayer's and reporter's tongues for zealously defendingthe work product of School auditors in revealing possibleSchool system complicity in over-billing by AshBritt,but where has she been?Invisible.I might've made a mistake in voting for Murray last year,but trust me, I won't repeat that mistake NEXT YEAR.
And I'm far from alone on that score.
And what about School Board member Jennifer Gottlieb?
What exactly has she done of late to show anyone payingattention that her performance is one marked by eithermerit or a commitment to zealously guarding the taxpayerswallet?
Tell me, does her being referred to as "nice" by mostpeople I interact with at civic events or public gatherings,somehow translate into her having a guaranteed govt. jobfor life, at least in Broward County, regardless of howpoorly she actually performs those oversight and legislativeroles?I keep wondering if my time in Washington around peoplewho were well-known and highly-regarded for good reason,makes me, therefore, somehow unqualified to comprehendwhat Jennifer Gottlieb's special ability or talent is, to theextent that she's able to get elected to public office for nodiscernible reason.I say that because I've yet to see anything on South FloridaTV or read anything in any newspaper or blog, that left meclearly thinking afterwards that I'd seen some glimpse intosome expertise, skill or insight that could reasonably explainwhy Gottlieb got elected in the first place.That has never happened.That doesn't make Gottlieb unique in South Florida,of course, just part of a very, very long list of peopledown here who prove the ultimate validity of thePeter Principle.http://www.businessweek.com/managing/content/mar2009/ca20090331_822526.htm
This area has always been noted for having moreunqualified candidates than other parts of the country,and that's been true for decades.This is, after all, a part of the country where someonewho genuinely couldn't speak English, ran for Congressnot once but three times in the 1970's and '80's. And got votes.Gottlieb's big accomplishment over the past year hasbeen what, exactly, urging the School Board to casta meaningless ceremonial vote last Fall against theproposed constitutional amendment that would bangay marriage?
Like anyone cared what they thought?
I should also mention here that a lot of the well-informedpeople I've spoken to and become friendly with sincelast November's election, have made a point of telling me,almost always with a resigned sigh in their voice,what a big disappointment Jennifer Gottlieb has beento them.
How they are truly dismayed at the extent to which shenot only carries the water like a drone for the BrowardTeachers Union, the BTU, but also for her starringrole in what happened to Lincoln Park in Hollywood,after the whole neighborhood made such an inspiredeffort to make it more attractive and useful for everyone.Contrast that with how it looked immediately after theSchool system got hold of it and neglected it.The latter effort is particularly galling to some folks inHollywood, even among those who don't live in thatimmediate neighborhood, who continually bring it upin conversations with me about other Broward Countymatters -as if I'd forget.But the truth is, what really rankles these folks to theircore is how the two of them together, Gottlieb andMurray, have really caused them to doubt their ownability to judge people, i.e. political candidates.Some have told me that while they may well have voted for long-shot candidates in the past, in otherplaces they've lived, since they (and their families)moved to South Florida, they've really tried to bediligent about finding out facts about local candidates'background and experience, however they could.Obviously the Internet has been a big help with thateffort, because they now could look for archivalarticles and columns online and have more info tobase their decision on, and pass that info along tofriends and familyThey stated that because of this effort to be well-informed,they rarely had voted for someone for whom theyhad immediate voters' remorse for.But the practical experience of Gottlieb and Murrayin office, as opposed to them in campaign mode,had really disabused these folks of their belief thatonce in office, the two would be diligent representativesof the public who'd be more demanding and moreassertive about the actions and policies of the BrowardSuperintendent and his staff.Instead, they elected two women who just shrug andvote for whatever the pack wants, consequences bedamned.To those community activists in particular, who reallypride themselves on not just keeping well-informedabout what's going on hereabouts, but even knowingwhat's going to happen BEFORE it does, and why,the combination of first Gottlieb and now MurrayBOTH being such self-evident wash-outs on reformand accountability, and not making any tangibledifference for Broward kids and taxpayers, representsa real big poke in the eye.
And it stings!Like me, these folks in Hollywood and elsewherearound the county are recalculating and recalibratingtheir political antennae to make sure that those verymistakes are not repeated in 2010.It's my belief that Broward County simply can't afford more wasted votes on people who fail thebasic test of being truthful before and after an election,and faithful to their constituents' best interests at all times.Those wasted votes on the Broward School Boardhave had very real consequences, because they'veempowered an otherwise clue-less and tone-deafperson like School Board member Stephanie Kraftto show voters and taxpayers her true colors.On June 16th, Kathy Bushouse of the Sun-Sentinel captured this institutional tone-deafness perfectly inher Broward Politics blog post, School District may ask voters to approve higher taxeshttp://weblogs.sun-sentinel.com/news/politics/broward/blog/2009/06/school_district_may_ask_voters.html#commentswhich concluded quite ridiculously:Voters may be more inclined to support a tax increase if theyknow what they might lose without it, said board memberStephanie Kraft."Honestly, I've already gotten several e-mails from people saying,'What about that project? What about that project? " Kraft said."A lot of people have indicated that they may not be opposedto doing something to get those projects built."That's the very creepy mentality that's gotten the county'staxpayers into the dire situation that Bob Norman hasbeen writing about aggressively for months from hisDaily Pulp blog, even as local South Florida TV stationshave largely washed their hands of even trying to explainthe story or identify who the villains and heroes are.In his blog today, Derelict School Board Wants More of Your Moneyhttp://blogs.browardpalmbeach.com/pulp/2009/08/broward_school_board_tax_increas.phpand yesterday's post titled,
Hollywood People Stand Up for School Board Auditorshttp://blogs.browardpalmbeach.com/pulp/2009/08/hollywood_folks_stand_up_for_s.php#commentsNorman has shown just what's been going on duringthe recent sleepwalking reign of Jennifer Gottlieb and more recently, while Ann Murray slept.